The list price of £380,000 seems reasonable considering the property’s location in Penarth and the presence of a garden. However, the lack of square footage information and the property’s condition (requiring some level of modernization) prevent it from being considered exceptional value. The comparable properties in the nearby listings provide a benchmark but lack sufficient detail to provide a definitive price per square foot which would significantly aid in the analysis of the price relative to other properties. Therefore, a moderate score of 7 is given.

Based on the provided photographs, the property appears to be in fair condition. While it is habitable, the interior decor and fixtures show their age and would likely benefit from some updating and modernization. The kitchen and bathrooms, in particular, seem dated, and overall the property shows signs of wear and tear. Although there’s no evidence of major structural issues, the current state of the property is not considered to be in excellent condition.

The property is located in Penarth, Vale of Glamorgan, which is a desirable area in South Wales. Its proximity to good schools like Evenlode C.P. School and Stanwell School, and relatively close to Penarth Train Station adds to its appeal. While the provided data lacks specific details about the immediate neighborhood’s amenities and character, its general location within Penarth suggests a good score.

The property includes a garden of moderate size, visible in the photographs. While not exceptionally large, it offers a decent outdoor space, which is better than many properties in urban areas. This reasonable size outdoor space justifies the higher-than-average score.