The list price of £284,000 seems reasonable considering the apparent condition of the property, the location, and the presence of a garden. While average price per square foot data is missing, the price aligns fairly well with other nearby properties of a similar type and apparent quality. However, a more precise assessment requires a deeper understanding of the local market conditions and detailed property specifications. The lack of precise square footage data for comparative properties also presents a challenge.

Based on the provided photos, the property appears to be in excellent condition. It has undergone a recent refurbishment or renovation, which is evident from the modern kitchen, bathroom, and flooring. The interior is presented well, and the exterior has also been freshly painted. There is no visible evidence of significant repairs or renovation needed.

The property is located in the Buttrills area of Barry, which benefits from proximity to several schools (Ysgol Sant Curig, High Street Primary School, Ysgol Sant Baruc, All Saints C.I.W. Primary School, and Gladstone Primary School) and is within a reasonable distance from Barry town centre and its amenities. The availability of public transport (Barry train station is approximately 1.10 km away) adds further value to the location. However, the specific desirability of Buttrills compared to other areas in Barry requires further local market knowledge for a more precise score.

The property includes a garden that appears to be well-maintained and of a reasonable size for a semi-detached house in Barry. While not extensive, it provides a usable outdoor space. The paved patio area adds further practical appeal. The lack of precise plot size information makes precise scoring challenging.