The list price of £500,000 is arguably reasonable given the location. However, considering the extensive renovations needed and the lack of precise plot size information, a higher price may be difficult to justify without substantial investment. The comparison with nearby listings is hampered by missing square footage data which would have provided an accurate price per square foot comparison.

The photographs clearly show the property is in significant need of renovation. Damage is visible in multiple rooms, including ceiling collapse and water damage. The kitchen and bathroom fixtures, while functional, appear dated and require updating. This extensive need for repair justifies the low score.

Effingham Common benefits from a desirable semi-rural location within easy reach of Effingham Junction station, providing convenient access to London and surrounding areas. The proximity to good schools, as noted in the provided data, further enhances its appeal. However, the limited information on immediate local amenities necessitates a slightly conservative score.

While the property includes some outdoor space, as evidenced by the photos of a small garden and what appears to be a yard, the plot size is listed as 0.00 sqft. This discrepancy and lack of detailed information prevents a higher score. The available area seems modest rather than extensive.